Staying Strong (and Profitable) This Holiday Season

We thought 2024 was a bad year for prices, but 2025 is proving to be the same story. This year, more than ever, consumers are feeling the pinch: they’re paying more for the same goods and services, which means businesses will be chasing fewer dollars this holiday season. To stay profitable in Q4, small business owners need to sharpen their strategies now—before the holiday rush hits. Let’s spend some time reviewing strategies for survival as summer winds down.

Understand the Challenge

Inflation continues to squeeze consumers’ wallets, reducing discretionary spending and pressuring small businesses to do more with less. Rising costs from supplies, labor, and utilities are shrinking margins, while consumer buying power remains strained. Adding to that complexity, tariffs and rising input costs are keeping retail prices elevated, even as consumers push back. U.S. shoppers are trading down and cutting back on non-essential purchases, embracing coupons, generic brands, and value deals.

Set Realistic, Margin-Focused Goals

This holiday season’s growth is projected to be modest—industry forecasts estimate only about 1.2 percent year-over-year sales growth. Use that as a baseline when setting targets, and forecast conservatively. Every discount should be intentional, so be sure to use pricing tools to weigh margin impact vs. incremental sales.

Emphasize Value Via Bundles

With consumers hunting high and low for bargains, value messaging always wins. Create product bundles or “under $25/$50” offerings—to boost average order value while keeping perceived costs down.

Be Transparent About Price Changes

If price increases are inevitable, don’t hide them! Let customers know why costs have gone up—simple transparency helps preserve trust and loyalty.

Optimize Operational Efficiency

Inflation demands leaner operations. Cut overhead via energy-efficient upgrades or outsourcing non-essential tasks like marketing or bookkeeping. Additionally, consider evaluating supplier pricing and negotiating better terms to preserve margins.

Dynamic, Tiered Pricing Strategies

Use pricing strategies like “good–better–best” tiers to cater to both budget-sensitive and premium buyers—anchoring value while boosting profitability. Consider dynamic pricing tools to adjust offers based on demand, competitor moves, or shopping behavior.

Leverage AI and Tailored Experiences

Consumers respond to personalization. Use AI-driven tools—like chat assistants or tailored recommendations—to guide shoppers and convert browsing into buying.

Capture Customer Data Now

Data is king, and the holiday season is your best chance to collect customer emails and preferences through sign-ups, loyalty programs, or text-based opt-ins. This customer data is critical in fueling next year’s targeting, promotions, and product planning.

Monitor Trends & Adapt in Real Time

Track weekly performance against your “best” and “worst” case scenarios, and be ready to adapt (whether that means tightening promos or pivoting campaigns) as the season unfolds.

Unfortunately, higher prices might be here to stay—so expect consumers to be spending more thoughtfully this holiday season. And as the summer winds down and the holidays kick into high gear, be sure to stick with the Financial Pantryfor the latest trends, tips, and financial advice your small business needs!

Your privacy is important to us. ARF Financial will never sell or rent your information to any third party. Click here for more information about our privacy policy. Image by DC Studio on Freepik